Who Is Doing the Meaning-Making in Your Coaching Sessions?
The Subtle Shift Most Coaches Miss
One of the most important shifts in developing coaching mastery has nothing to do with better questions.
It has everything to do with where meaning is created.
In early coach training we focus on structure, listening skills, contracting and impact. We work hard to stay client-focused and learn not to advise.
We practise to not interrupt and to give the client space.
And something more nuanced sits underneath all of that.
Even experienced coaches can unintentionally begin shaping the insights.
Not overtly but often with good intent.
It can appear as a shift in how we frame our words; or providing a summary that goes ahead of the client’s thinking; or an interpretation offered a fraction too soon.
It sounds supportive and can even sound insightful but when that happens the centre of focus shifts.
When Meaning Moves Towards the Coach
Meaning is no longer forming entirely in the client’s mind and it begins, subtly, to coalesce in ours.
There is also something else that creeps in.
We start to assume we know what the client means so we fill in gaps.
We translate their words into our language and we move over ambiguity before they have finished exploring it.
Again, the intent is positive because we want to help. We want clarity and we want our client to progress.
Yet the moment we begin to create the insight for them, or subtly construct the learning, the developmental impact is significantly reduced.
You can feel the difference in the room.
When the coach is shaping the meaning, the session is more directed. There is movement but it is guided by the coach steering where it is going.
When the client is constructing meaning for themselves, there is space, more silence and more searching but what emerges belongs to them, which is much more powerful.
Why This Becomes Visible at PCC
This is precisely where many coaches find the ICF PCC level challenging.
Not because they lack skill or they don’t understand the competencies but because they are, often very subtly, making meaning on behalf of the client.
They articulate the insight just ahead of the client.
They consolidate learning in their own words.
They infer what the client must be thinking or feeling and move the conversation from that assumption.
From the outside, it can sound polished and even impressive.
From an assessment perspective, however, the question becomes clear:
Whose thinking are we hearing?
At PCC, as an Assessor I am listening carefully for evidence that insight and learning are unmistakably generated by the client, not crafted by the coach.
Outside of assessment, it matters even more.
Because coaching that leaves meaning firmly with the client builds autonomy.
It builds confidence and strengthens their capacity to think independently long after the session ends.
Reflective Practice at a Deeper Level
None of us are neutral observers. We bring our preferences, our pace, our speed of thought.
Under pressure to do a good job, or when we care deeply about offering value, those strengths can quietly move to the foreground. We may find ourselves interpreting more quickly, summarising more confidently, connecting dots before the client has quite finished laying them out.
So reflective practice at this level becomes more intentional.
.Instead of asking “Am I asking good questions?” ask
- Where was insight actually forming in that conversation?
- What assumptions did I making about what my client means?
- At what point did I begin to consolidate meaning?
- Where might I have stepped in just a fraction too soon?
A Developmental Question to Carry Forward
In your next session, when you sense insight beginning to form, allow yourself a brief internal pause and consider:
What would happen if I let this unfold completely in the client’s language?
Notice what changes when you hold that position.
I’d genuinely be interested to hear what you discover as you experiment with this in your own practice.
Until next time
Cath
x
P.S. If You Want to Examine This Properly
This level of nuance rarely shifts through self-study alone.
It benefits from careful observation, transcript review and someone willing to point gently to where meaning moves towards you which is exactly the work we do in my ICF Accredited Coach Development and Mentoring Programme.
If you’re considering going fro your ICF Credential or simply want to explore this in your coaching you’re welcome to get in touch for a conversation.
Click here to book a call with me.
